• 2016 – Erin Lammers, University of Kentucky
  • 2014 – Elizabeth Holt, University of Mississippi
    • Runner-Up – Ivy Riley, Jackson State University
  • 2013 – Haley Sims, University of Mississippi
  • 2011 – Kelsey Ford, University of Memphis
    • Runner-Up – Evan Schalton, UNC-Charlotte 
  • 2010 – Jennifer Johnson, Clemson University
  • 2009 – Jeffery Karafa, The University of Memphis
  • 2008 – Alexander Shoemaker, Auburn University
    • Runner-Up – Francisco Moraes Oliveira-Neto, University of Tennessee
  • 2007 – Zachary Bugg, Mississippi State University
    • Runner-Up – Katherine Osborne, University of Mississippi 
  • 2006 – Kevin Miller, North Carolina State University
  • 2005 – Preston Denson, University of Mississippi
  • 2004 – Rachel Elizabeth Abel, University of Virginia
  • 2002 – Will Letchworth, Ben Crawford, Jeff Dayton, Adam Snipes,
    Mark Johnson and Wayne Jacas, N.C. State University
  • 2001 – John Gibbs Townsend, Clemson University